Room for Wiggling: Local Swaps for the Thanksgiving Table
We have felt a distinct shift in seasons and energy in the last month. For me, that shift inspires a desire to be cozy and to cook. I pull out the candles from last winter, restock the tea cupboard, find my slippers, and dig out recipe cards. Okay, now I am ready for Thanksgiving.
Thanksgiving meal from 1993. I am the one eyeing the cranberry sauce.
From a young age, my brothers and I knew what to expect at the Thanksgiving dinner table: the annual question, "What are you thankful for this year?" My mom predictably asked this as we passed festive platters of food around the table.
It wasn't until I was a young adult studying agricultural systems and environmentalism that I expanded my response beyond "cranberry sauce!" (Yes, the picture here is me smiling and staring at the log of cranberry sauce.)
I was starting to learn about the labor that went into growing my food, the environmental impact of consuming meat, the ways in which indigenous peoples have stewarded the land, and the staggering amount of food waste in this country. I was suddenly grateful for the people who grew my food, the land that produces such magic, and the privilege of having enough food.
At Thanksgiving, as gardeners and farmers, or as individuals interested in supporting local agriculture and economies, we might feel a tension between cooking the things we grew up eating and the beloved things we or our farmer neighbors grew. The Thanksgiving foods we love might not always align with local, organic, or sustainable values.
What to do with that tension? First, I want to acknowledge that maybe some things aren't worth messing with (at least for one day per year). For me, something that fits in that category is the canned cranberry sauce that makes that schlorp sound when plopping out of the can and remains in the shape of the can until it's in your mouth. While I suppose I could try, I don't grow cranberries.
Maybe for you it is something different?
While there might be some untouchables for you or your family and friends, maybe there is some room for wiggling in local farm and garden ingredients. Over time, I have integrated some new ingredients without rocking the boat too much. Here are a few things I have tried and would highly recommend.
Yearning for Something Green and fresh?
You must try this root vegetable salad! I think this is the absolute best way to eat parsnips, and you can get many of the other ingredients locally as well (carrots, arugula, onion, herbs, honey).
Looking for an easy crowd pleaser?
Roasted delicata squash is delicious and super easy to prepare! You could even cut the squash the day before, and then you only need to schedule 25 minutes in the oven on the day of. You can eat the tender skin of delicatas, so you can skip the tedious peeling motivate for tedious peeling. Just add salt, pepper, and olive oil and throw them in the oven. For specifics, here’s a basic recipe: Love & Lemons: Roasted Delicata Squash.
Will these potatoes work?
Mashed potatoes – nobody will know you used your garden potatoes! ! In fact, they might even be better than the big bag you buy at the grocery store. The thing to keep in mind is that starchy potatoes are best. The traditional russet is great, and so is Yukon Gold. If you are pondering a variety beyond those two, maybe consider experimenting at a small scale on a friend a week before Thanksgiving, just to be sure. Or go for roasting instead of mashing.*
*Note: doing anything besides mashing is a dangerous choice if your adult brother has been saying he is thankful for mashed potatoes since he could talk. (Yes, that is a picture of him, above, with his finger in his mouth because he could not wait to try the mashed potatoes.) Read the room!
Love & Lemons: Best Mashed Potatoes (below) calls for Yukon Gold or russet, and comes with make-ahead tips for the big day.
Are cranberries your only reasonable fruit option?
If you don't love the canned cranberry sauce, there are some fun local fruit choices: berry jams, applesauce or apple butter, pepper chutneys?! Pear chutney recipe below! And file this away for next September, or check your own pantry and the winter market for local jams this week.
Pumpkin pie, but without a pumpkin?
Pssst… pumpkin pie doesn't have to be made with a pumpkin. If you've got a good pumpkin source, great, but don't worry if not. Kabocha, butternut, and red kuri squashes all work, so be adventurous. You want something that is a bit less fibrous and on the sweeter side, but when you add enough butter and sugar, it's all really quite forgiving. I suspect you could substitute in a squash other than pumpkin and your uncle wouldn't even notice.
Do I have to eat all of the leftovers right now?
So, you've had a lovely Thanksgiving meal, and everyone has recovered from the post-meal stupor. It's leftovers day… or week… or month… eek. If you made too much food, it's worth doing a quick calculation the day after Thanksgiving of what you will actually eat before you are sick of meal after meal of stuffing (or dressing, depending on where you grew up… no intention to inspire any debates here). One of the great things about typical Thanksgiving food is that most of it (sorry, pie) can be frozen! Load that freezer up and dig things out on a dark January day. Your later self will thank you, and you won't have to go through the misery of coming up with new combinations for eating huge amounts of leftovers. Turkey and cranberry sauce on bread, anyone?
While I will continue to be grateful for cranberry sauce, I love putting my sustainable agriculture values on the table for Thanksgiving. The tension may never fully go away, but it's fun to create new traditions while still preserving some old ones.